Trafalgar, Indiana

Your Trusted Partners in Indiana Real Estate

Serving central and south-central Indiana for over 20 years. Whether you're buying your first home or selling a family property, our 13-agent team is here to guide every step.

About Us

Indiana's Hometown Real Estate Team

Trusted Realty Partners of Indiana is a full-service real estate brokerage rooted in Trafalgar, IN. Led by Managing Broker Jeff Eisenmenger and also known as The Eisenmenger Group, our 13-member team brings deep local knowledge, unwavering integrity, and a genuine passion for helping families find their place in Indiana.

From first-time buyers to seasoned investors, from starter homes to rural farmsteads, we've helped clients across 16 Indiana counties achieve their real estate goals — with an average sale price of $237,000 and a price range extending from $24K to $730K.

Buyer's Agent Listing Agent Foreclosure Specialist New Construction English & Spanish

Meet Our 13-Agent Team →

Current Listings

Featured Properties For Sale

Browse a selection of homes currently listed by Trusted Realty Partners of Indiana.

$364,900

4231 Saffron Dr
Indianapolis, IN 46237

4 Beds3 Baths

$342,900

9378 Green Rd
Trafalgar, IN 46181

4 Beds2 Baths

$298,000

503 E Park St
Trafalgar, IN 46181

3 Beds2 Baths

$239,900

211 Cindy Ln
Crothersville, IN 47229

3 Beds1 Bath

$199,999

8779 N Briarwood Lake West Ct
Monrovia, IN 46157

2 Beds1 Bath

→

See All Listings

View the complete portfolio on Zillow

Why Trusted Realty Partners

What Sets Our Team Apart

We combine deep local roots with a results-driven approach so every client feels informed, supported, and confident.

Deep Local Roots

Our agents live and work in the communities they serve. From Trafalgar to Indianapolis, we know the neighborhoods, schools, market trends, and hidden gems that matter to your decision.

Proven Results

With 125 transactions in the last 12 months and a proven track record spanning 363 total sales, we have the experience to negotiate the best price — whether you're on the buying or selling side.

A Team Behind You

You're never alone in your transaction. With 13 dedicated agents, you get the personalized attention of a boutique firm backed by the resources and reach of a full brokerage team.

Client Reviews

What Our Clients Say

Our 5.0-star Zillow rating comes from clients who experienced our commitment firsthand.

★★★★★

"Matthew Keeton is an outstanding realtor! He made selling my house a breeze. His expertise in the local market was evident from our first meeting, and his advice helped make the process smooth and successful."

Lance EstesSold a home · October 2025

★★★★★

"Kirk did a great job finding us the right home at the right price and got us connected with a local mortgage company, which was a great help. I highly recommend him for any real estate needs."

Mary DentonBought a home in Franklin, IN · 2024

★★★★★

"Matthew was awesome at getting everything we needed and was very supportive every step of the way! He is kind, professional and trustworthy. He watches market trends and truly has your best interests in mind."

Verified Zillow ClientBought & sold in Shelbyville, IN · 2025

Read All Reviews on Zillow

Coverage

Our Service Areas

We proudly serve 16 counties and communities across central and south-central Indiana.

Johnson County

Marion County

Morgan County

Shelby County

Hamilton County

Hendricks County

Bartholomew County

Boone County

Brown County

Monroe County

Decatur County

Rush County

Fayette County

Ripley County

Connersville Area

Central Indiana

Your Trusted Partners in Indiana Real Estate

Indiana's Hometown Real Estate Team

Featured Properties For Sale

What Sets Our Team Apart

Deep Local Roots

Proven Results

A Team Behind You

What Our Clients Say

Our Service Areas

Ready to Make Your Move?